Successful Ethereum with Worthless ETH?

Successful Ethereum with Worthless ETH?

Jeremy Rubin, a technical advisor to Stellar and a Bitcoin Core contributor, explains how ETH the currency can become worthless, while Ethereum the platform prospers

In his article on TechCrunch, Rubin presents and rationalizes a possible future scenario where ethers as an asset have no market value whatsoever, despite Ethereum’s massive adoption.

Rubin first takes a look at Ethereum’s official description and underlines that it provides no value proposition for ETH. He goes to say that the value of ETH derives from the value of Ethereum only because users need to use ETH to pay for gas which powers smart contracts. Rubin then explains why economic abstraction, i.e. paying for gas in other assets, is a better approach.

Rubin clarifies that Ethereum can adopt a system where users can pay for gas in contract tokens, e.g. ERC-20 tokens. When one uses the ‘BuzzwordCoin’ contract, they simply transfer a necessary amount of BuzzwordCoins to the block’s miner as transaction fees. This relieves users from the need of converting tokens to ETH before interacting with the contract, and tokens do not depend on ETH’s market value.

Counterarguments to economic abstraction

There are four counterarguments to the economical abstraction of Ethereum:

  1. the lack of software support for economic abstraction
  2. difficulty in pricing many tokens
  3. the existence of contracts not tied to tokens;
  4. the need for ETH for Proof-of-Stake.

Software support

Opponents of economic abstraction claim that ‘the added complexity is not worth the ecosystem gains’. In response to this, Rubin argues that if the software does not meet the needs of its userbase, then it should be altered to do so.

Market pricing

To mine on economically abstracted Ethereum, miners simply need software which orders pending transactions based on available pricing information on corresponding tokens, which is already the case.

Non-token contracts

A user of a tokenless contract can pay in whatever asset they want. If a miner does not want those assets, the miner can process fees through a DEX and exchange the tokens for more preferred ones.


Stakeholders do not need to hold ETH to have voting power. The community can still establish consensus by using a variation of PoS dubbed Heterogeneous Deposit PoS by Rubin. In HD-PoS, each node determines the voting power of each asset, or a weight vector, and if all weight vectors are similar enough, consensus is possible. There is yet much research to be done in this area, Rubin adds, but if an HD-PoS algorithm proves impossible, this failure is only a shortcoming of Ethereum PoS specifically.

If all the applications and their transactions can run without ETH, there’s no reason for ETH to be valuable unless the miners enforce some sort of racket to require users to pay in ETH. But if miners are uncoordinated, mutually disinterested, and rational, they would prefer to be paid in assets of their own choosing rather than in something like ETH

Jeremy Rubin, tech adviser at Stellar, Bitcoin Core contributor


272.72 USD -8.76%
0.03118000 BTC 2.16%
Volume, 24h
2,405,210,584 USD
28,549,930,014 USD

Related news

Poll: Majority Of Respondents Would Rather Buy ICON (ICX) Than Ethereum For Long Term Investment

The 2018 bear market has ravaged Bitcoin and altcoins alike. While Bitcoin has made significant recovery from its 2018 low of $3,200, most altcoins are still battling to find their footing. A Twitter poll involving 4 altcoins shows that users are more willing to buy ICX than other three alts including Ethereum. The poll had 1,842 respondents answer the question “if you have to choose ONLY one alt for the long term, with the highest chance to get back the ATH.” Out of the number, 49% indicated optimism that ICX is most likely to get back to its all-time high while the remaining 3 had 51% of the votes to share.  Not very surprisingly, ETH had the second-highest vote of 31% who would go for it in the hope of getting back to its all-time high and making some profits from it. The next was NEO with 14% of the votes while Ontology (ONT) came last with 6% of the votes, with the least chance of ever seeing its all-time high price again. The poll also gave room for those whose favorite coins were not listed to mention them in their comments. Guess what? ICX was still mentioned roughly 99% of the time, which raises the question of why ICX? Well, ICX is the native token of one of the largest blockchain projects in the world, ICON. It’s working towards bringing blockchain application to the real world in all areas including banking, healthcare, and education. It also provides scalability for both public and private blockchains as well as enabling interoperability between chains. There are several other projects with similar goals but ICX seems to have found a place in the hearts of crypto users worldwide. Its price performance is still subpar as it has lost over 8% in the last 24 hours, ICX supporters, however, believe it’s soon going to reach its all-time high once again. Some experts question the possibility of another alt season but with this level of support, who knows what may happen in the future? The post Poll: Majority Of Respondents Would Rather Buy ICON (ICX) Than Ethereum For Long Term Investment appeared first on ZyCrypto.

Iran Recognizes Cryptocurrency Mining as a Proper Industry

Iran Gives Cryptocurrency Mining a Nod In a move easily juxtaposed with US policies on cryptocurrency, the government of Iran has officially recognized cryptocurrency mining as an independent industry. A move on July 21st by the Iranian Chamber of Commerce, Industries, Mines, and Agriculture ratified an economic commission approving crypto mining as a legitimate industry. The committee also passed a previous proposal to apply export rates for electricity used by domestic miners. Similarly, Deputy Minister of Electricity and Energy Homayun Haeri stated that government ministers would later vote on an approved electricity rate for mining farms. Later deliberations on government regulations will be held in a cabinet meeting, as announced by the Governor of the Central Bank of Iran (CBI), Abdolnaser Hemmati. Despite the recent legitimacy procured by the Iranian mining community, the sea to legal cryptocurrency mining in Iran has been far from smooth sailing. A statement made by the Iranian Energy Ministry in late June announced that mining processes increased national electricity consumption by seven percent over the summer. This is due to the nation’s relatively low electricity rates, making mining attractive and profitable to cryptocurrency enthusiasts. The ministry consequently proposed for electricity export rates to be applied to miners, a bid echoed by the Iranian government on Sunday. Following the lead of the Energy Ministry, the Iranian Power Generation and Distribution Company (known locally as TAVANIR) had previously announced that using electricity for mining purposes is illegal and household of commercial users found to be mining cryptocurrency would be cut off from the national grid. In addition to the previous protests from Iranian energy executives, earlier statements made by Iranian officials included a recommendation by the CBI to bar cryptocurrency for domestic payments in January 2019, marking the future of cryptocurrency as a payment method in Iran uncertain. Despite this, the recent backpedal on mining by the CBI seems to be foreshadowing a victory for cryptocurrency in Iran, with Iranian enthusiasts hopeful for the future. Title Image Courtesy of Aleksi Raisa The post Iran Recognizes Cryptocurrency Mining as a Proper Industry appeared first on Ethereum World News.
Ethereum World News

DigiByte’s latest hash algorithm, Odocrypt, claims to improve mining experience

There is always a Yin for a Yang, with many major businesses swimming against the tide by integrating their operations with blockchain technology. Following a growing adoption rate, blockchain technologists are building innovative technologies in order to get ready for mainstream adoption in the near future. A majority of the miners are deterred from mining […] The post DigiByte’s latest hash algorithm, Odocrypt, claims to improve mining experience appeared first on AMBCrypto.

Hot news

By continuing to browse, you agree to the use of cookies. Read Privacy Policy to know more or withdraw your consent.